Analysis, Commentary

The False Choice Between Family Separation and Detention

Texas Detention Facility

The Tornillo facility, a shelter for children of detained migrants, in Tornillo, Texas, U.S., is seen in this undated handout photo provided by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, obtained by Reuters June 25, 2018. © 2018 Reuters

ICE Has Abandoned an Effective Alternative That Keeps Families Free

NEW YORK—(ENEWSPF)—June 26, 2018
By: Clara Long

As US President Donald Trump ended his appalling mass family separation policy on the US southern border, he claimed a false choice: the US government either needs to separate families that cross the US border or detain them together. But family detention is not the best or only alternative to family separation – other approaches exist that are both just and fair.

They are also much cheaper than detention.

A problem the US faces is the high rates of no-shows at immigration court for  asylum seekers released without supervision and support. How can we change this?

One alternative the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency piloted was the Family Case Management Program, which had 630 asylum-seeker enrollees as of April of last year. In the program, social workers helped participants in five US cities navigate the immigration court system, get housing and health care, and enroll their kids in school. Of those participating, 99 percent attended their immigration hearing and check in requirements and it cost only $36 dollars a day per family. That’s in contrast to an average cost of $319 a day per person in family immigration detention and $124 a day in adult facilities.

In spite of its great promise as a humane and cost-effective alternative to detention,  the Trump administration yanked the program last year, even paying the contractor an early-termination fee. According to an ICE official, one reason for the decision was the relatively lower rates of deportation orders in the pilot group. It stood to reason that people who had access to attorneys and a fair chance to make their case were more often approved as bona fide refugees. What the administration should be doing is dramtically ramping up this program.

ICE has also tested other alternatives to detention, often focusing its resources on intrusive “intensive supervision” programs using bulky GPS ankle monitors. Women are the lion’s share of the over 70,000 people who had been fitted with these devices as of this year. I’ve spoken with several women who report that they cause bruising, need to be charged constantly, and carry heavy societal stigma.

Human Rights Watch has long advocated against the unnecessary use of immigration detention, particularly of families with children.

Congress can and should act. Instead of family separation or family detention – and indiscriminate immigration detention of adults alone – Congress should pass legislation that implements humane, dignified, and effective alternatives.

Related Material:

Trump’s Cruel Separation Policy Has Not Ended


Related Articles:

Stephen Colbert Addresses Trump’s Cruel Immigration Policy of Separating Immigrant Parents from Their Children

As World Commemorates 70th Anniversary of Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Looks Like Trump About to Ditch UN Human Rights Council

Military Contractors Making Tens of Millions Helping Trump Tear Families Apart

Attorney General Madigan Comments on Trump Administration’s Inhumane Immigration Policies

Former First Lady Laura Bush Calls Family Separations Cruel And Immoral

Michelle Obama on Laura Bush Op-ed: ‘Sometimes Truth Transcends Party’

Watching as US Officials Take Children from Their Parents

American Academy of Pediatrics Statement Opposing the Border Security and Immigration Reform Act

Attorney General Madigan Calls on Jeff Sessions to Immediately End Enforcement of Inhumane Immigration Policies

New Video and Audio Captures ‘Horrifying’ Reality of Children Taken From Parents as GOP Pressed to ‘Find Their Conscience’

Mass Mobilization Planned for June 30 to Protest Trump’s Cruel Separation of Families

Amnesty International: Policy of Separating Children from Parents is Nothing Short of Torture

House Republicans’ Immigration Bills Hurt Women and Children, Says Center for American Progress Column

Jeff Sessions’ Separation of Families Results in Charges of Child Abuse and Immorality From His Own Church

‘Shut This Place Down’: Children Drugged and Given Forced Injections at Texas Detention Facility, Lawsuit Says

Mass Demonstrations at LaGuardia Airport as Kids Ripped From Parents Arrive in New York

Rep. Barbara Lee Urges UN to Probe Trump’s Human Rights Abuses at Border as Violation of International Law

‘Abu Ghraib for Eighth-Graders’: Allegations of Immigrant Children Being Tortured at Virginia Detention Facility

Attorney General Madigan Joins Multistate Lawsuit Challenging Trump Administration’s Family Separation Policy

With Human Rights Crisis Still Underway, Fast to End ‘Zero Tolerance’ Takes Aim at Trump’s Cruelty

‘Both Illegal and Unconstitutional’: Trump Brazenly Suggests Immediate Deportations, Zero Due Process

Senator Warren After Visiting Child Detention Facility: ‘What I’ve Witnessed Here Is Truly Disturbing’

With So-Called ‘Voluntary’ Deportation, Trump’s DHS Using Children as Bait to Expel Immigrants

Detained Children Forced to Recite Pledge of Allegiance ‘Out of Respect’ for Country That Tore Them Away From Parents

Whistleblower Leaks Video From Detention Facility Where Children Were Threatened Against Speaking to Press

‘Guilty of Kidnapping 2,500 Children’: Protesters Hand Out ‘Missing’ and ‘Wanted’ Posters at Stephen Miller’s DC Home